RUMORS: Yankees-Cardinals Nolan Arenado trade possibility gets harsh reality

Nolan Arenado will not be a Yankee.

The St Louis Cardinals are looking to trade Nolan Arenado this offseason. After another year of missing the playoffs, they are kicking off a rebuild. Over in the American League, the New York Yankees need improved infield defense and another impactful bat. The connection was easy to make and rumors were swirling connecting the Bombers to Arenado. YES Network’s Jack Curry poured cold water on that idea on Tuesday night.

“In talking to Yankee officials about Arenado, the answer that I was given was they have a lot of respect for the player that he has been and the player he still is,” Curry reported. “But now, at this moment, not a fit. It is not somebody they are out there seeking. I think at that price tag and at who he was last year, the Yankees absolutely believe there are better options.”

The Yankees signed Max Fried to an eight-year contract with the highest guarantee to a lefty pitcher ever. This report came after that, crushing one of the many trade options for the Bombers. Their new toy creates a massive surplus at starting pitching, which they could deal from for a hitter. That will not come in an Arenado deal.

Where should the Cardinals look for Nolan Arenado trade?

MLB rumors: Yankees-Cardinals Nolan Arenado trade possibility gets harsh reality
Jeff Curry-Imagn Images

The issue for the Cardinals is they are trying to unload three years of an aging infielder. Small-market teams are likely out, as Nolan Arenado has over $70 million left on his deal. The Dodgers also took their hats out of the ring, so the two biggest markets are out. Where should the Cardinals turn?

Related New York Yankees NewsArticle continues below

The Angels play in the second-biggest city in the country but are not thought of in the big-market conversation. They are almost done with the Anthony Rendon contract and could bring in Arenado to usher along their young prospects. They have already spent a lot of money this offseason and could add to their team.

The Washington Nationals are looking to power out of their rebuild this offseason. Bringing a former MVP to the young Nationals team would help them compete in a loaded NL East. It will be tough for them to land a free agent with their loaded division, so a trade would be some great business.


Christopher Hennessy is an MLB associate editor at ClutchPoints, with additional expertise in the NHL and golf. He graduated with a journalism degree from Fordham University in 2022, and he has work experience at Spectrum News One in Albany, New York and with The Hockey Writers as a New York Islanders reporter.

Related Posts

BREAKING: Chicago Cubs Trade Cody Bellinger to Yankees in Cost-Saving Deal, Strengthening New York’s Lineup

The Chicago Cubs have traded former MVP Cody Bellinger to the New York Yankees in a cost-saving move, with the Yankees covering most of his salary for the

MLB insider calls for Philadelphia Phillies to make franchise-altering trade for this All-Star

A top MLB insider believes the Phillies Phillies still need to improve the offense and believes the team should trade for this All-Star.

Dodgers GM Provides Injury Timelines For 2 Key Relievers Who Were Injured During Postseason

Dodgers relief pitchers Alex Vesia and Evan Phillips, who endured postseason injuries, are reportedly expected to be healthy for Opening Day.

REPORT: Dodgers GM Provides Latest Injury Update on Tyler Glasnow

Dodgers general manager Brandon Gomes provided the latest update on starting pitcher Tyler Glasnow at the Winter Meetings in Dallas. Glasnow was sidelined in September because of…

THE ONLY WAY!!! The Dodgers Seemingly Could Have Easily Brought Back Walker Buehler

The Los Angeles Dodgers had the option to bring back Walker Buehler this offseason, but they chose not to, leaving fans wondering what might have been. Los…

Loáisiga secured a one-year contract with the Yankees worth $5 million as he makes his comeback

Right-handed pitcher Jonathan Loáisiga has signed a one-year contract with the New York Yankees, which guarantees him $5 million as he returns from Tommy John