Cowboys Nation, brace yourselves! A former NFL receiver has just thrown a grenade into the offseason with a scorching-hot trade proposal: send safety Malik Hooker to the Cleveland Browns for superstar pass rusher Myles Garrett! Is this a stroke of genius or a recipe for disaster?!

Hooker Out, Garrett In?! The Trade That Could Redefine Dallas!

While no names have been confirmed as part of a supposed trade for Garrett, Bleacher Report’s Alex Kay suggested a package that included two first-round picks (2025, 2026) and two third-round selections (2025, 2026) in exchange for Garrett[1].

That said, the hypothetical trade of Hooker for Garrett has now captured the attention of fans and analysts alike, sparking heated debate about its potential impact on both teams.

Is Hooker Expendable?

Hooker is staying put with the Cowboys, and in 2022, the Cowboys agreed to a new two-year, $8MM deal with the veteran safety[5].

He is a solid player, there’s no doubt about that.

But with other talented safeties on the roster, is he the most valuable piece to dangle in a trade for a generational talent like Garrett?

Is it worth trading a member of the secondary to potentially strengthen the defensive line?

### Garrett to Dallas: A Dream Come True?

Garrett has publicly expressed his desire to play for the Cowboys, his hometown team[3]. In an old video that resurfaced, Garrett even had a trade worked out–Tony Romo and picks going to the Browns, with Dak Prescott taking over at QB[3].

“Make it happen,” he said[3]. “Dak Prescott is leading that team right now. I need you to take Tony Romo, take a couple picks and give them to Cleveland so you can pick me up. Please. I’d love to play in Dallas. Make it happen”[3].

### Jerry’s Gamble: Win Now or Build for the Future?

The Cowboys are dealing with significant injuries to star pass rushers Micah Parsons and DeMarcus Lawrence[1]. Adding Garrett would undoubtedly elevate the Cowboys’ defense to elite status[1].

However, it would involve parting with valuable draft capital and taking on Garrett’s lucrative contract[1].

Could this bold move propel the Cowboys to a Super Bowl title, or would it mortgage the team’s future for a short-term fix?